When Good Designers Go Wrong
Posted on July 15th, 2008 by shoesense under Alexander McQueen Shoes, Boots, Chloe Shoes, Christian Louboutin Shoes, Pumps, Sandals, Walking DisastersThis is what I’m talking about: you see a cute-as-a-button shoe, just adorable, and then you check the brand, and it’s some cheapo, Chinese-made, all man-made materials low-end shoe and you wrinkle your nose and say, I’ll pass, thank you, so what if it’s only $19.99, it’s not worth it to me.
And then you go into a Fendi or Louis Vuitton or Bottega Venetta boutique and you see a blah or fuglirific product that is, granted, well made (although that doesn’t mean it can’t be made out of plastic entirely) and you fawn over the craftsmanship and say, well, I know it’s $790, which is my rent for the month, but it must be really worth it if they charge so much money for it.
There are high end shoes out there I wouldn’t look at twice unless their exorbitant sticker price didn’t compel me. Just to be clear, they’re not all horrendous or anything, just something I wouldn’t be caught dead in–an example in which the otherwise world-renown taste of the designer is a little…off.
Let’s start with the “blah” range:

I know, it’s a “basic nude” or something, but honestly, $690 for this? Ok, it’s a Bottega Veneta, but that doesn’t make it more palatable.
And these boots–I find them swerving from blah to ugly:

But they’re Chloe and $775, so I’m guessing they’ll have a lot of takers among the snobbish crowd.
And the king of stilettos himself is asking for $1,575 of your hard-earned money for this fringed monstrosity:

But it’s a Louboutin, and I bet that come fall I’m going to see these fringes swaying vigorously around the ankles of many a Hollywould starlet.
Speaking of fringes (I had posted about this trend a while back, and to my horror, I notice more and more of it lately)–I find these distasteful:

And yet, they’re $1,075 because they’re Alexander McQueen. I bet you feel differently about them now, don’t you? There’s so much magic in the name of the designer! A shoe you would have only deemed fit for the 4 a.m. shift in Place Pigalle or to go in circles around a shiny pole is suddenly a work of art worthy of an entire paycheck.
And Zanotti, you king of zany, what the heck are these?

While I appreciate their fashion-forwardness, their aesthetic is a bit…off. The balance is no good. The harmony is missing. Plus, they’re $750.
I guess in the world of fashion, the old Shakespearean rhyme wouldn’t apply: “What’s in a name? That which we call a rose/By any other name would smell as sweet.”
Sometimes, in this world, name is everything.
- It’s all in the details
- Ask the Shoebloggers: Shoe Brand pronunciation
- Eco-Friendly Shoes
- Cute-as-a-button Seychelles Pumps
- Cordani: A shoe that’s made for walking
- Friday Shoe History Corner: Fairy-Tale Edition


Piperlime
July 15th, 2008 at 6:59 am
Hi there! I just wanted to let you know that I awarded you with the Premio blogging award. http://style-ology.com/?p=86
Keep up the good work!
July 15th, 2008 at 9:35 am
You are so right! Why, just the other day at DSW I saw the most adorable shoe and ran to it only to drop it like a hot potato when I saw it was *gasp* a Jessica Simpson. I’m really not that bad of a shoe snob - I buy most of my summer sandals at DSW, after all! Still, I’d rather have a few very nice shoes than a closet full of cheapos but they must be beautiful. I would not plunk down ridiculous amounts of cash just for a name. For 700 bucks I want something elegant and timeless. Some of these shoes look like they came from the Frederick’s of Hollywood catalog.
July 15th, 2008 at 9:37 am
[…] like Shoesense, I am sometimes baffled by the exhorbitant prices charged for designer shoes. Innovative design may count for something, and quality of materials, sure. But there’s a […]
July 16th, 2008 at 3:44 am
Well i don’t really care how expensive these shoes are, as long as it is comfortable to wear.
August 3rd, 2008 at 11:28 pm
[…] Shoesense quite neatly beat me to the punch regarding fringed footwear. I can’t help but shudder when I see many of the […]
August 19th, 2008 at 8:03 pm
Hey. If it has a huge price tag, it must be great-even if it is ugly and makes you look like a mop. Remember those Manolo/Timberlands?? I never did understand that. When they were “in”, I saw 3 girls’ heels get stuck in the manhole covers. Hilarius.